An arrest can happen fast, and the moments right after are when people accidentally make choices that hurt their case. Whether it’s a misunderstanding, a heated situation, or a serious allegation, what you say and do immediately matters.
At Mirela Piroli Law Firm P.C., we defend clients in serious criminal cases and also represent people in civil rights matters like police brutality and wrongful convictions.
Below are 7 practical steps to protect yourself if you’re arrested or taken in for questioning in New York.
Important: This blog is general information, not legal advice. Every case is different. If you’re dealing with an arrest, speak with a lawyer as soon as possible.
1) Stay calm, and don’t resist
Even if you believe the arrest is unfair, resisting can create new charges or escalate the situation. Keep your hands visible, follow instructions, and focus on protecting your legal position.
2) Ask, “Am I free to leave?”
If you’re stopped or questioned, a key question is whether you’re being detained or you’re free to go. If they say you’re free to leave, leave calmly.
3) Use your right to remain silent (and mean it)
This is one of the biggest mistakes people make: trying to “explain” their way out. Even innocent details can be misunderstood, recorded inaccurately, or used later.
A simple, respectful line works best:
“I’m invoking my right to remain silent.”
Then stop talking.
4) Ask for an attorney immediately
If you’re being questioned or arrested, say:
“I want a lawyer.”
Once you request counsel, do not keep answering questions “just to be helpful.” Make the request and stop.
Mirela Piroli Law Firm’s practice includes criminal defense across a wide range of charges, including serious felony-level accusations.
5) Don’t consent to searches
If officers ask to search your phone, car, home, or belongings, you can respond calmly:
“I do not consent to a search.”
This preserves your rights. Never physically interfere.
6) Don’t discuss your case on jail calls or texts
Assume calls, messages, and social media can be monitored or screenshotted. Limit conversation to:
- arranging bail support
- getting contact info to reach your attorney
- basic logistics (medication, childcare, work notification)
7) Write down everything you remember (as soon as you can)
As soon as it’s safe, write:
- time and location
- officer names/badge numbers (if known)
- what was said, and in what order
- witnesses and camera locations
- any injuries or property damage
This can be crucial—especially in cases involving rights violations. The firm also handles civil rights matters including police brutality and wrongful convictions.
Common Questions After an Arrest
“Should I explain my side so they let me go?”
Usually, no. What you say can be used against you, even if you’re trying to help. The safest move is to invoke your rights and speak through counsel.
“What if the police say they ‘just need a quick statement’?”
Treat it seriously. If you’re being questioned, your words matter. Ask for a lawyer.
“Do you handle cases outside Manhattan?”
Yes. The firm lists service areas including Manhattan, Brooklyn, Bronx, Queens, plus White Plains and Bergen County.
Call to Action
If you or a loved one is facing an arrest, don’t wait until the situation gets worse. Get guidance early, protect your rights, and build a strategy from day one.
Mirela Piroli Law Firm P.C.
📍 159 West 25th Street, Suite 516, New York, NY 10001
🕘 Hours: Monday–Friday, 9:30am–6pm
📞 Office: (917) 300-9908
✉️ Email: mirela@pirolilaw.com